Carrot & Onion Bed

The classic pair: onion scent deters carrot fly, carrot scent deters onion fly.

Bed 100 × 200 cmEasy

Season timeline

Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
  • Direct-sow the carrots
  • Plant the onion sets
  • Pull early bunching carrots
  • Harvest the onions
  • Lift the maincrop carrots
  • Clear the bed

Bed layout

Carrot5 cmShallot10 cmCarrot5 cmShallot10 cmCarrot5 cmShallot10 cmCarrot5 cm

Crops in this bed

Step by step

  1. Direct-sow the carrotsMar–Apr

    Sow carrots thinly in shallow rows as soon as the soil crumbles; germination can take three weeks.

  2. Plant the onion setsMar–Apr

    Push the sets into the rows between the future carrot rows, tips just showing.

  3. Pull early bunching carrotsJun–Jul

    Harvest every other root as tender bunches; the rest gains room to size up.

  4. Harvest the onionsJul–Aug

    Once the tops yellow and fall over, lift the bulbs and let them dry in an airy spot.

  5. Lift the maincrop carrotsAug–Oct

    Lift the remaining carrots as needed; they hold in the soil until the first frosts.

  6. Clear the bedOct

    Remove the last roots and spent foliage, and compost only healthy material.

Harvest calendar

CropJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
Carrot
Carrot: Jun
Carrot: Jul
Carrot: Aug
Carrot: Sep
Carrot: Oct
Shallot
Shallot: Jul
Shallot: Aug

The bed over the season

Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
  • Carrot · Sowing
  • Carrot · Growing
  • Carrot · Harvest
  • Carrot · Harvest
  • Shallot · Sowing
  • Shallot · Growing
  • Shallot · Harvest

Why this combination works

Carrot fly hunts by scent, and so does onion fly. When carrot and onion rows alternate, each crop’s smell masks the other, so both pests struggle to find their target. The two vegetables also root at different depths — onions sit shallow while carrots reach deep — so they never compete for the same water and nutrients. Alternating rows make the most of a narrow bed without any extra work.

Tips

Sow carrots thinly and thin them in the evening — the scent of bruised foliage attracts carrot fly. Firm onion sets into the soil just deep enough that the tip still shows. Water evenly; carrots split after sudden heavy watering. Never plant onions into freshly manured soil.